Buttondown vs Substack: Developer Simplicity vs Network Effects
Comparing Buttondown and Substack for newsletters. Minimal and developer-friendly vs platform and discoverability.
Overview
Buttondown and Substack both offer simple newsletter tools, but for different audiences. Buttondown is minimal and developer-friendly. Substack offers platform benefits and network effects. The choice depends on whether you value independence or discoverability.
The quick answer: developers and minimalists should choose Buttondown. Writers wanting platform benefits might prefer Substack.
| Feature | Buttondown | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Developers | Writers |
| Pricing | $9/mo | Free + 10% |
| Free Tier | 100 subscribers | Unlimited |
| Markdown Support | Native | Limited |
| API Quality | Excellent | Basic |
| Network Effects | None | Strong |
| Customization | High | Limited |
| Revenue Share | 0% | 10% |
Key Differences
Target Audience
Buttondown is built for developers and technical writers. Native Markdown support, clean API, minimal interface. No bloat, no unnecessary features.
Substack is built for general writers. Rich text editor, platform discovery features, app experience. More approachable for non-technical users.
Business Model
Buttondown charges a flat monthly fee starting at $9/mo. No revenue share. You keep 100% of what subscribers pay.
Substack is free but takes 10% of paid subscription revenue. Great for starting out, but the fee adds up at scale.
Platform vs Independence
Substack offers network effects. Readers discover new newsletters through the app. The Substack brand can lend credibility. You are building within their ecosystem.
Buttondown is just infrastructure. No network effects, but complete independence. Your newsletter is fully yours.
Pros and Cons
Buttondown
Pros
- + Native Markdown
- + Clean API
- + No revenue share
- + Minimal design
- + Full independence
Cons
- - Small free tier
- - No network effects
- - Less discovery
- - Developer-focused
Substack
Pros
- + Free to start
- + Network effects
- + Platform discovery
- + Substack brand
- + Simple editor
Cons
- - 10% revenue share
- - Limited customization
- - Platform dependency
- - Basic API
Who Should Choose What
Choose Buttondown if:
- You are a developer or technical writer
- You prefer Markdown
- You want to keep 100% of revenue
- Independence matters more than discovery
- You value minimal, focused tools
Choose Substack if:
- You want zero upfront costs
- Network effects benefit your niche
- You prefer a rich text editor
- Platform discovery is valuable
- Simplicity outweighs technical features
For SaaS Startups
Neither Buttondown nor Substack is suitable for SaaS product email. Both are newsletter tools, not marketing automation platforms. For SaaS, use Sequenzy for product email with billing integration. Run a personal newsletter on Buttondown or Substack separately.
The Bottom Line
Buttondown is the better choice for developers who value independence and minimal tooling. The flat pricing keeps 100% of your revenue as you grow.
Substack makes sense for writers starting out who want zero upfront costs and potential platform discovery. Just be aware the 10% adds up at scale.
Looking for more comparisons?
Check out our full comparison of 15+ email marketing tools for startups.
View Full Comparison